Skip to main content

Fiscal responsibility: Kaduna State's debt burden and unrealistic budgeting


By YUSUF ISHAKU GOJE

The budget is said to be the second most important document outside the constitution, without which even the constitution cannot fully function. It enables governments to turn campaign promises articulated as policies into concrete public services that seek to improve the overall living standard of the people. That is why it remains the most critical socio-economic policy tool that outlines the government's priorities in financial terms.

The extent to which the government's proposed spending sticks to what it has projected as realistic revenue makes a budget credible. Therefore, it also becomes a measurement of government's sincerity and capacity to deliver on campaign promises. More importantly, the credibility of any budget depends on its realism, as you cannot spend what you cannot get. That means for a budget to be realistic it has to be substantially achievable.

However, politicians are always under pressure to spend more, most times overshooting projections made in the Medium Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF). They do this by including revenue sources that they know are not realizable by the end of the fiscal year. Ideally, the MTEF ensures that the government's expenditure does not exceed the total sum of projected total revenue.

Kaduna state has since 2014 embraced the culture of medium term planning through the MTEF. This has improved the quality of the annual budget as a result of the technical and evidence-based approach therein. Consequently, it has also thrown up the debate on budget realism. The trend since 2016 to 2020, have shown that the government had not adhered to the MTEF recommended budget size. This is worrisome.

The actual performance within the same period, the exception being 2019 as a result of a supplementary budget passed, has been closer to the MTEF recommendations than to the final approved budgets. For instance, in 2016 the MTEF recommended N94 billion but was inflated to N172 billion in the approved budget; while the actual performance was N80 billion. Similarly, in 2020 the actual performance was N190 billion, even though slightly higher, is closer to the MTEF recommendation of N178 billion, than the approved budget of N259 billion.

Commendably, the external debt service versus total revenue, total debt service versus total revenue, and domestic debt service versus IGR are all below the threshold. However, the fact that we all must come to terms with is that the debt profile of the state is high. This is evident as the total public debt for Kaduna state was N284,398,612,174 as at 31st December, 2020. This is broken down into domestic debt, which is N68,754,361,084; while external debt stands at N215,644,251,090.

More importantly, our focus should be on the ratio between total domestic debt versus total recurrent revenue which is 64%, above the 50% threshold; total domestic debt versus IGR is 156%, above the 150% threshold; total external debt versus total revenue is 201%, above the 50% threshold; total public debt versus total revenue is 265%, above the 100% threshold. This should give us sleepless nights particularly because the 2022-2024 MTEF also shows that in 2021 about N71,687,054,660 and in 2020 about N30,475,012,034 are earmarked as loans.

Even though we are still within the debt service threshold, which might look convenient in the short term, the worry is our capacity to sustain this in the future. This is if we consider the large chunk of the debt, made up of the World Bank P4R loan, with a moratorium of ten years before we start paying back. Granted that the state government's investment and revenue drive should be commended, a closer look leaves one with some concern.

The questions to be answered about our repayment capacity. Would insecurity allow for inflow of massive investments and boosting of agriculture's contribution to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP)? How many micro and small businesses is the government supporting, considering that the Urban Renewal projects' (Market Component) has displaced many of them? Is the upward IGR spike sustainable considering that the Federal government refund and and other recoveries will end one day? What happens if that ends? Also, is the statutory 10% and revenue collected on behalf of the local government part of what is being declared? What happens if the local governments are granted autonomy in the future?

The reality is that there is no better option than for the government to strictly adhere to realistic budgeting now. Thankfully, at the recent MTEF Stakeholder's Engagement, the Planning & Budget Commission has made a commitment to adhere to the recommended 2022-2024 MTEF budget size. The total budget size for the year 2022 is put at N197,563,002,078. This is realistic and if it is adhered to it will make the budget more credible with improved prioritization.

Finally, we call on the government to always base its annual budgets on realistic projections of all sources of revenue. This will not only ensure credibility but also close the trust gap with the citizens. It will also ensure that we move closer to addressing our socio-economic challenges as a state.

Goje, is a good governance advocate and writes from Kaduna-Nigeria

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Coalition cautions against Nigeria's Disunity

  N etwork for Better Nigeria, a coalition of concerned Civil Society Organizations in the 19 Northern States has responded to  the growing tension threatening national unity and socio-economic development of the country and called on President Muhammadu Buhari to urgently collaborate with the governors in the 19 northern states and critical stakeholders to arrest the lingering insecurity in Nigeria. In a joint statement signed by Mallam Isiaku Abdulhameed, the coalition in collaboration with Arewa Youth Consultative Youth Movement, Arewa Youth Assembly and Chanchanta stated inter Alia:  "the Federal Government should urgently collaborate with the Northern State Governors and come up with a modernistic livestock development policy which will not only provide solutions to the herders/farmers crises but transform the age long traditional open grazing towards providing additional economic value for pastoral communities. Equally, we wish to express our support on the position...

Environmentalists re-strategize on governance

A cross-section of environmental strategists at the event Lack of good and well-intentioned environmental governance and social audit for effective monitoring and evaluation of data and procurement have been identified as the major impediment against the climate change campaign in Kaduna state. A leading member of Network of Civil Societies in Environment, Gloria Kasang Bulus, who made this known during a one-day capacity building platform for critical stakeholders working around environment - strengthening the technical working groups; to develop or use tools required for effective engagement with government, urged participants to volunteer wholeheartedly in the task ahead - to mitigate climate change. Bulus who is also the Director, Bridge that Gap Initiative and convener of the network noted that, "Unless and until we are able to partner the government in ensuring outcomes in tandem with the people oriented policies, plans, appropriations; we will be doing next...

Open Budget: Kaduna seeks citizens' input in 2020 Budget

F ollowing sustained campaign by concerned citizens and critical stakeholders in Kaduna state to open up the budget cycle, the Governor el-Rufa'i-led administration, during the week, engaged the representatives of the academia, community-based organizations, the civil society, women groups and individuals on state's 2020 to 2022 Medium Term Expenditure Framework(MTEF) to make next year's budget budget realistic and realizable. The event tagged 'Citizens Consultations on 2020-2022 MTEF' which was put together by the state's Planning and Budget Commission with the support of DFID-funded Partnership to Engage, Reform and Learn (PERL), took a critical look at strategies to forge a people-centered budget with emphasis on transparency, openness and accountability. Co-chair of the Open Government Partnership(OGP) in the state, Alhaji Mustapha Jumare told participants that as a sub national, Kaduna state was indeed a trail brazer in nation's quest ...

Environmentalists intensify action against global warming!

A cross section of the Network of Civil Society in Environment being welcome by the commissioner (Centre) I n a bid to cushion the increasing adverse effects of global warming on the environment, non-state actors under the aegis of Network of Civil Society in Environment (NCSE), during the week in Kaduna, sought for a robust partnership with the state's Environment and Natural Resources Ministry to address numerous environmental challenges facing the state. Receiving the group who were on an advocacy visit to the Ministry, the Honourable Commissioner of Environment and Natural Resources, Hon. Ibrahim Garba Hussain expressed delight over the renewed move to mitigate environmental degradation and pledged his support for the initiative. "Climate change is all as result of the activity and action of man. It might interest you to know that the Ministry has put together a comprehensive policy document on environment. That is why I am very pleased to welcome you peo...

SEMA engages Zaria communities on disaster risk reduction strategies

  Executive Secretary, Abubakar Hassan (center) and his team at Zaria By EDDY OCHIGBO V ulnerable communities and wards in and around Zaria and its environs have been sensitized and strengthened to tackle possible disasters, ranging from gully erosion, insecurity, fire and rape vis-a-vis the ongoing environmental hazards awareness campaign across Kaduna state. Keen watchers believe that the move - which is aimed at system strengthening on emergency coordination and response strategy - in collaboration with the United State Agency for International Development's Nigeria Early Recovery Initiative (NERI) would drastically reduce peoples' vulnerability and possible disasters in the state. "To prevent disasters, we must get the people equipped and prepared to understand what constitutes hazards, risks etc., as well as what they should do to identify early warning signs and signals. The exercise is taking place in all the wards and communities in Tudun Wada, Sabon Gari, Zaria Ci...