Skip to main content

Anniversary Feature: A Toast for Nigeria @ 59




By Yusuf Goje

The fundamental difference between dictatorship and a liberal democracy is the existence of the legislative arm in the latter. The legislative arm empowers the people via direct representation of their elected legislators to amplify and reflect their voices (needs) in decision-making process; such as in law-making, appropriation and other national or state issues. It is envisaged that the legislative arm either at the Federal or State level should be the closest link between the people and government. As the legislators are expected to regularly consult their constituents on legislative issues to be tabled and provide feedback on the resolutions reached at the Assembly.

In view of the foregoing, Nigeria which practice a Federating system  with the States as component units has seen section 90 of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) of the Federal Republic of Nigeria establish the House of Assembly of a State; while section 100 provides for the mode of exercising legislative powers of a state Assembly. The unicameral Kaduna State House of Assembly is one of such creation of the constitution, which is presently having its 6th Assembly with 34 State constituencies represented through their elected legislators.

At this juncture, it is worthy of note to single out the 5th Assembly for being the first nationally to pass an unprecedented 82 bills out of a total of 86 that were considered within four years. This surpasses the number of bills passed across the country, with 79 bills from the executive arm and only 7 as private members bill. However, even though worthy of commendation, this has gotten tongues wagging. 

With 34 legislators contributing only 8.5% (private member bills) and the State government having 91.5% of the total bills passed within four years, one is compelled to reflect on the openness of the Assembly as regards their engagement with constituents and civil society. Does this means that there is more engagement with and openness to the executive arm than their constituents and civil society?

However, the 5th Assembly had its high and low moments especially in the area of citizen’s engagement with a number of contentious and reform driven bills. Starting on a positive note, the Assembly was commended by the civil society on a number of occasions for opening its doors for citizen’s engagement and inputs. This happened especially during the Committee public hearings on the Kaduna State Planning and Budget Law 2017 and the Peace Commission Law 2017. 

Furthermore, the civil society had the opportunity to submit our budget analysis to the Assembly for consideration during the 2018 appropriation process, even though it did not reflect in the final approved budget. The civil society also had a sympathetic partner in the former House Committee on Information and later Deputy Speaker, Honorable Nuhu Shadalafiya, who was always willing to engage with us on legislative issues.

On the flipside, the Assembly carried out proceedings and passed bills that the civil society felt that adequate citizen’s consultations and engagements were not carried out. For instance, on the 27 December 2017, there was accelerated passage of the second and third supplementary budgets of 1.5 billion for the State’s Commercial Agricultural Development projects and 17.7 billion for road construction and water project totaling 19.2billion. 

The passage of this supplementary budget (in a day, some say in less than an hour) should probably go into the Guinness Book of record as the fastest; more so, that it was passed only a few (approximately four) days to the end of the year and without adequate citizen’s engagement. So also, the passage of the Religious Preaching Regulation bill, in June 2019, into law by the Assembly on the last day of the 5th Assembly, which had sparked debates since it was submitted as a bill to the Assembly in 2016.

Now that the 6th Assembly has been fully constituted and the Honorable Speaker, Alhaji Aminu Abdullahi Shagali, has retained his seat, the expectations of the citizens have gone higher. Even though, the civil society has observed that some of the approach of restricted-engagement with the civil society has continued. For instance, the Kaduna State House of Assembly passed 81.68 billion naira supplementary budget necessitated by the injection of funds received by the Planning & Budget Commission. In passing the supplementary budget, the Assembly set aside rule 3(1) and 7 of their Standing Order to fast track the process without citizen’s engagement or input. 

It is this trend that has necessitated my write up so as to deepen the conversation #OpenKDSHoA by setting a civil society agenda for the 6th Assembly. It is no longer news that Kaduna state has joined the Open Government Partnership (OGP) both at the National and Global level (first sub-national in Nigeria to do so). This means that the government has committed to governance reforms that promote transparency, accountability and responsiveness to citizen’s engagement and needs. There is no doubt the assembly has a critical role to play in the areas of appropriation and passing relevant laws that will strengthen the implementation of the principles of OGP.

The key agenda to be set here for the Assembly are majorly in line with three out of the five commitments of the Kaduna State Action Plan (2018-2020) on OGP. They include: Open Budget, Access to Information and Citizen’s Engagement; just for the sake of information the others are: Open Contracting and Ease of Doing Business. Nonetheless, I must commend the 5th Assembly under the leadership of the incumbent Speaker, who had already passed a number of key laws in this regards. Therefore, the areas that the 6th Assembly needs to focus on now are improving citizen’s engagement in the appropriation process, speedy consideration of Audit reports and domesticating the Freedom of Information (FoI) Act - which has been lying in the Assembly for years now. 

On appropriation, which falls under the OGP commitment on Open Budget (ensure more effective citizen’s participation in the entire budget cycle), the Assembly since 2015 to date is yet to hold an Appropriation Committee or Sectorial Committee Public Hearing to consider citizens input into the budget. The 2020 budget process, however, presents another opportunity for the Assembly to open up its doors to citizen’s engagement through public hearing, just like it is happening at the National Assembly. While on Audit Report, the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) needs to fast track the consideration of the backlog of reports, hold public hearings and present her key recommendations to the executive arm for necessary and immediate action.

As regards the domestication of the Freedom of Information, the quality of citizen’s engagement is largely determined by the timely access to usable information, not just does the government proactively discloses. This is already a performance indicator in the OGP commitment on Access to Information; which states that, ‘FoI bill passed by State House of Assembly before the end of 2020’. Presently, while some MDAs are responding to the FoI Act (2011, as passed by the National Assembly), others have ignored the requests by the civil society. However, with the domestication, the powers of enforcing the FoI law will be transferred to the Attorney-General of the State as against that of the Federation in the Act. 

Another key performance indicator, which the Assembly is expected to play a key role in the OGP commitment on Open Budget, ‘is a bill on Community Development Charter (CDC) drafted and tabled before the Assembly’. Last but not the least, the Assembly needs a fully functional and interactive website that provides up-to-date information on its activities and feedback to citizen’s engagement.

The time is now to #OpenKDSHoA!

Happy 59th Anniversary to Nigerians!

Yusuf Ishaku Goje is Head Leadership, Governance & Advocacy, Coalition of Associations for Leadership, Peace, Empowerment & Development (CALPED) a Kaduna-based civil society organization inN Nigeria

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Coalition cautions against Nigeria's Disunity

  N etwork for Better Nigeria, a coalition of concerned Civil Society Organizations in the 19 Northern States has responded to  the growing tension threatening national unity and socio-economic development of the country and called on President Muhammadu Buhari to urgently collaborate with the governors in the 19 northern states and critical stakeholders to arrest the lingering insecurity in Nigeria. In a joint statement signed by Mallam Isiaku Abdulhameed, the coalition in collaboration with Arewa Youth Consultative Youth Movement, Arewa Youth Assembly and Chanchanta stated inter Alia:  "the Federal Government should urgently collaborate with the Northern State Governors and come up with a modernistic livestock development policy which will not only provide solutions to the herders/farmers crises but transform the age long traditional open grazing towards providing additional economic value for pastoral communities. Equally, we wish to express our support on the position...

Environmentalists re-strategize on governance

A cross-section of environmental strategists at the event Lack of good and well-intentioned environmental governance and social audit for effective monitoring and evaluation of data and procurement have been identified as the major impediment against the climate change campaign in Kaduna state. A leading member of Network of Civil Societies in Environment, Gloria Kasang Bulus, who made this known during a one-day capacity building platform for critical stakeholders working around environment - strengthening the technical working groups; to develop or use tools required for effective engagement with government, urged participants to volunteer wholeheartedly in the task ahead - to mitigate climate change. Bulus who is also the Director, Bridge that Gap Initiative and convener of the network noted that, "Unless and until we are able to partner the government in ensuring outcomes in tandem with the people oriented policies, plans, appropriations; we will be doing next...

Open Budget: Kaduna seeks citizens' input in 2020 Budget

F ollowing sustained campaign by concerned citizens and critical stakeholders in Kaduna state to open up the budget cycle, the Governor el-Rufa'i-led administration, during the week, engaged the representatives of the academia, community-based organizations, the civil society, women groups and individuals on state's 2020 to 2022 Medium Term Expenditure Framework(MTEF) to make next year's budget budget realistic and realizable. The event tagged 'Citizens Consultations on 2020-2022 MTEF' which was put together by the state's Planning and Budget Commission with the support of DFID-funded Partnership to Engage, Reform and Learn (PERL), took a critical look at strategies to forge a people-centered budget with emphasis on transparency, openness and accountability. Co-chair of the Open Government Partnership(OGP) in the state, Alhaji Mustapha Jumare told participants that as a sub national, Kaduna state was indeed a trail brazer in nation's quest ...

Environmentalists intensify action against global warming!

A cross section of the Network of Civil Society in Environment being welcome by the commissioner (Centre) I n a bid to cushion the increasing adverse effects of global warming on the environment, non-state actors under the aegis of Network of Civil Society in Environment (NCSE), during the week in Kaduna, sought for a robust partnership with the state's Environment and Natural Resources Ministry to address numerous environmental challenges facing the state. Receiving the group who were on an advocacy visit to the Ministry, the Honourable Commissioner of Environment and Natural Resources, Hon. Ibrahim Garba Hussain expressed delight over the renewed move to mitigate environmental degradation and pledged his support for the initiative. "Climate change is all as result of the activity and action of man. It might interest you to know that the Ministry has put together a comprehensive policy document on environment. That is why I am very pleased to welcome you peo...

SEMA engages Zaria communities on disaster risk reduction strategies

  Executive Secretary, Abubakar Hassan (center) and his team at Zaria By EDDY OCHIGBO V ulnerable communities and wards in and around Zaria and its environs have been sensitized and strengthened to tackle possible disasters, ranging from gully erosion, insecurity, fire and rape vis-a-vis the ongoing environmental hazards awareness campaign across Kaduna state. Keen watchers believe that the move - which is aimed at system strengthening on emergency coordination and response strategy - in collaboration with the United State Agency for International Development's Nigeria Early Recovery Initiative (NERI) would drastically reduce peoples' vulnerability and possible disasters in the state. "To prevent disasters, we must get the people equipped and prepared to understand what constitutes hazards, risks etc., as well as what they should do to identify early warning signs and signals. The exercise is taking place in all the wards and communities in Tudun Wada, Sabon Gari, Zaria Ci...